Satisfaction with relationship and better agreement are linked with positive health outcomes
Diagnosis and treatment of breast cancer places significant stress on survivors, their partners and their relationships. A new study from researchers with Regenstrief Institute and Indiana University’s schools of nursing, science and medicine is one of the first to examine the impact of relationship satisfaction and agreement between breast cancer survivors and their partners on the survivor’s emotional and physical health.
The study found that satisfaction with the relationship by both the breast cancer survivor and their partner and agreement between the two were related to survivors’ better physical functioning, such as carrying groceries or walking around the block, reduced survivor depression, and fatigue.
Conversely, less satisfaction with the relationship on the part of the breast cancer survivor and lack of agreement with their partner were both significantly associated with a number of poor emotional and poor physical outcomes for the breast cancer survivor including depression and fatigue.
“How the breast cancer survivor and partner communicated and handled stressful events, particularly those related to breast cancer, were linked to emotional and physical health for the survivor, with better agreement related to better outcomes,” said study corresponding author Eric Vachon, PhD, R.N., a research scientist with Regenstrief Institute and IU School of Nursing. “Interestingly, breast cancer survivors who rated their relationship satisfaction as high did not necessarily have better agreement with their partner or better well-being than those survivors who viewed their relationship less positively. It’s the communication and relationship between the survivor and partner that are determinant.
“The implication of this work for breast cancer survivors, their partners, clinicians, researchers and others involved with cancer care is that it can be extremely impactful to make sure that both the survivor and the partner are on the same page and are in agreement.”
A total of 387 women (220 breast cancer survivors on average six years out from time of diagnosis and 167 controls without previous cancer diagnosis) and 387 partners (all male although both male and female partners were eligible to participate in the study) completed questionnaires on their relationship. Average age of study participants was mid-40s.
“We knew from the literature that breast cancer survivors’ rating of their relationship satisfaction is linked with some poor physical and emotional outcomes,” said Dr. Vachon. “We took that knowledge to the next level and combined the breast cancer survivors’ and partners’ views of relationship satisfaction and relationship agreement and determined impact on survivors’ health.”
Among the study findings:
- breast cancer survivors’ satisfaction with the relationship with their partner was significantly associated with physical functioning, attention function and sleep quality.
- not all breast cancer survivors or controls who indicated high relationship satisfaction were in agreement with their partners.
- agreement with the partner was not associated with worse physical functioning, worse attention function, or poorer sleep quality.
- after the perspective of the partner was factored in, there was less agreement on the quality and satisfaction of their relationship for survivors than for control pairs.
“This work points to the critical importance of both members of the couple focusing on strengthening the relationship. Difficulties among couples can have devastating effects for your physical and emotional health. For clinicians, making sure that based upon the preferences of the breast cancer survivor, partners are involved in discussions, treatment, and overall care is vital to the short-term and long-term health of patients,” the study concludes.
This research was supported by the National Cancer Institute of the National Institutes of Health grants UG1CA189828 and UG1CA233320. Additional support was provided by the American Cancer Society.
“The Association between Relationship Satisfaction Concordance and Breast Cancer Survivors’ Physical and Psychosocial Well-Being” is published in a special issue, “Psychological, Cognitive and Physical Dimensions of Adjustment to Cancer: Perspectives of Cancer Survivors and Caregivers,” of the peer-reviewed open access journal Healthcare.
Regenstrief Institute authors, in addition to Dr. Vachon, are Research Scientist David Haggstrom, M.D., MAS, and Affiliate Scientist Victoria Champion, PhD.
All authors and affiliations
Eric A. Vachon1, 2, Ellen Krueger3, David A. Haggstrom2, 4, Victoria L. Champion1
1School of Nursing, Indiana University, Indianapolis, IN 46202, USA.
2Center for Health Services Research, Regenstrief Institute, Indianapolis, IN 46202, USA.
3Department of Psychology, Indiana University-Purdue University Indianapolis, Indianapolis, IN 46202, USA.
4School of Medicine, Indiana University, Indianapolis, IN 46202, USA
About Eric Vachon, PhD, R.N.
In addition to being a research scientist at the Regenstrief Institute, Eric Vachon, PhD, R.N., is an assistant professor at Indiana University School of Nursing and a researcher at the Indiana University Melvin and Bren Simon Comprehensive Cancer Center.
